What is the downside of painting brick and what to consider
|
Time to read 7 min
This article explores what is the downside of painting brick, shedding light on the challenges of brick painting to help you make an informed choice.
Brick painting can give your home a modern look, but it comes with several drawbacks that might make you reconsider. From trapping moisture to requiring ongoing upkeep, the process isn’t always as simple as it seems.
Read our exterior brick painting guide: This in depth guide covers everything from inspection, priming and painting house brick for a professional finnish.
Paintbrush Guard - Exterior Brick Painting
Table of contents
Moisture trapping and damage in brick painting
One major downside of painting brick is the risk of moisture trapping. Brick is a porous material that naturally absorbs and releases water, but brick painting creates a solid layer that can seal this process.
If the paint isn’t breathable, water gets trapped inside the brick, leading to peeling, cracking, or even structural damage over time.
In wet climates, this issue worsens, with brick painting potentially causing mold growth or efflorescence within 3 to 5 years. This makes what is the downside of painting brick a critical concern for long term durability.
This article explains whether you need to prime exterior brick before painting, covering benefits, exceptions, and practical steps for a professional result.
Paintbrush Guard - Do I need to prime before exterior brick painting?
Limited breathability with brick paint
Another drawback of brick painting is its impact on the brick’s breathability. Unlike bare brick, which allows moisture to evaporate, brick painting can block this natural ventilation.
Non breathable paints, often chosen for their low cost, exacerbate the problem, trapping dampness that weakens the brick over 5 to 10 years.
Even high quality, breathable brick painting options may not fully mimic the brick’s original state, reducing its ability to handle humidity.
This limitation is a key part of what is the downside of painting brick, especially in humid or rainy areas.
This article dives into is it better to paint or stain exterior brick, comparing brick paint and stain to guide your decision.
Paintbrush Guard - Is it better to paint or stain exterior brick? Pros & cons
High maintenance demands
Brick painting requires significant maintenance, adding to what is the downside of painting brick. The paint layer is prone to chipping, fading, or peeling, particularly in harsh weather, necessitating inspections every 6 months.
Touch ups with matching brick painting every 5 years and a full repaint every 10 to 15 years keep it looking good, but this demands time and effort.
Bare brick, by contrast, needs little more than occasional cleaning. The ongoing care needed with brick painting can become a burden for homeowners.
Learn more about brick and limewashing: This article explores if it's better to limewash or paint brick, comparing the two methods to help you choose the best option.
Paintbrush Guard - Is it better to limewash or paint brick? Pros and cons.
Aesthetic limitations over time
The aesthetic appeal of brick painting can fade, contributing to what is the downside of painting brick. Over time, the paint may crack or discolor, losing the fresh look you started with after 7 to 12 years.
This can make the brick appear worn or patchy, especially if the original color clashes with a faded finish. Bare brick ages gracefully, developing a natural patina, while brick painting requires constant effort to maintain its beauty. This aesthetic challenge is a notable drawback for those considering brick painting.
Cost implications of brick painting
Cost is a significant part of what is the downside of painting brick. Initial brick painting for a 1,000 square foot wall runs 1,500 to 3,000 dollars, including paint, primer, and labor.
Touch ups cost 200 to 500 dollars every 5 years, with a full repaint at 1,000 to 2,500 dollars every 10 to 15 years.
These expenses add up, especially compared to the low maintenance cost of unpainted brick, which might only need cleaning every few years for 100 to 300 dollars. The financial commitment of brick painting can strain budgets over time.
Brick and whitewashing: This article explores is whitewashing brick out of style, examining current trends, aesthetic shifts, and practical considerations with brick paint.
Paintbrush Guard - Is whitewashing brick out of style? Examining current trends
Difficulty of removal
Removing brick painting presents another downside of painting brick. Once applied, paint is hard to strip without damaging the brick, often requiring chemical strippers or sandblasting at 2,000 to 5,000 dollars for a 1,000 square foot wall.
This process can leave the brick scarred or discolored, undoing its natural charm. Unlike other surfaces, brick painting is nearly permanent, making what is the downside of painting brick a long term consideration if you change your mind later.
Environmental impact
The environmental effect adds to what is the downside of painting brick. Brick painting involves chemicals that can harm the environment if not disposed of properly, especially with frequent repaints.
The production and application of brick painting also consume more resources than leaving brick natural. In eco conscious areas, this can conflict with sustainable building practices.
The ecological footprint of brick painting makes it a less green option, influencing what is the downside of painting brick for environmentally minded homeowners.
Maintenance requirements
Maintenance challenges deepen what is the downside of painting brick. The need to monitor for peeling or fading every 6 months can feel overwhelming, with touch ups required every 5 years to prevent further damage.
A full recoat every 10 to 15 years with brick painting keeps it intact, but harsh weather accelerates wear, demanding more frequent care.
Cleaning with mild detergent yearly helps, but the effort outpaces the minimal upkeep of bare brick.
- Regular inspections catch peeling early, reducing repair costs.
- Touch ups restore faded areas, maintaining the brick’s appearance.
- Sealing with a breathable coat every 5 years minimizes moisture issues.
- Avoiding high pressure washing protects the brick painting layer.
Learn more about brick color:
This article explores what is the best color to paint brick, offering options and advice to help you achieve a stunning look with brick painting.
Paintbrush Guard - What is the best color to paint brick? Appeal and durability
Cost comparison
Cost factors highlight what is the downside of painting brick. Painting a 1,000 square foot wall initially costs 1,500 to 3,000 dollars, with brick painting at 30 to 60 dollars per gallon, plus primer and labor.
Touch ups run 200 to 500 dollars every 5 years, and repainting reaches 1,000 to 2,500 dollars every 10 to 15 years.
Unpainted brick maintenance is cheaper, with cleaning at 100 to 300 dollars every few years. DIY brick painting saves 500 to 1,000 dollars but still adds up over time.
- Initial investment includes high quality brick painting for durability.
- Frequent touch ups increase costs with light or fading colors.
- Long term savings favor unpainted brick over repeated brick painting.
- Labor charges vary by region, impacting total expense.
Learn more about brick painting:
This article has explored the benefits, drawbacks, and alternatives, helping you determine if painting brick aligns with your goals.
Paintbrush Guard - Is Painting Exterior Brick a Good Idea? Pros, Cons and Tips
Final considerations
What is the downside of painting brick? The risks of moisture trapping, limited breathability, high maintenance, fading aesthetics, removal difficulty, cost, and environmental impact make brick painting a complex choice.
While it offers a quick refresh, these drawbacks can outweigh benefits for some homeowners.
Consider your climate, budget, and long term plans before starting brick painting. Test samples to assess the look, and weigh the effort against the natural beauty of bare brick. This decision shapes your home’s future!
What is the downside of painting brick?
The downsides of painting brick include moisture trapping that can lead to peeling or structural damage, limited breathability causing dampness issues, high maintenance with frequent touch-ups, aesthetic fading over 7–12 years, difficulty and cost of paint removal, environmental impact from chemicals, and high long-term costs compared to unpainted brick.
How does painting brick affect moisture and breathability?
Brick painting can trap moisture in porous brick, leading to peeling, cracking, or mold within 3–5 years, especially in wet climates, if non-breathable paint is used. Even breathable brick painting reduces natural ventilation compared to bare brick, potentially weakening the structure over 5–10 years in humid or rainy areas.
What are the maintenance and cost implications of painting brick?
Brick painting requires inspections every 6 months, touch-ups every 5 years ($200–$500), and repainting every 10–15 years ($1,000–$2,500 for a 1,000-square-foot wall). Initial costs are $1,500–$3,000, while unpainted brick only needs cleaning ($100–$300 every few years), making painted brick more demanding and costly over time.
Why is removing painted brick challenging, and what are the environmental concerns?
Removing brick painting is difficult and costly ($2,000–$5,000 for 1,000 square feet), requiring chemical strippers or sandblasting that may scar the brick. Environmentally, brick painting involves chemicals that harm ecosystems if improperly disposed of, and frequent repaints increase resource use, conflicting with sustainable practices.
What should I consider before deciding to paint brick?
Consider your climate (wet areas risk moisture issues), budget (initial and ongoing costs), maintenance commitment (frequent touch-ups and repaints), aesthetic goals (fading versus natural patina), removal challenges, and environmental impact. Test brick painting samples and weigh these against bare brick’s low maintenance to ensure a lasting, practical choice.
Mark Walsh
Written by Mark Walsh, a home improvement specialist with over 15 years of hands-on experience in interior painting. Mark has completed hundreds of DIY and professional projects, from basic wall refreshes to complex textured applications, and is passionate about sharing practical, beginner-friendly advice to help homeowners achieve lasting, professional-quality results.
This article explores how long will painted brick last, the key influences on its durability, and practical steps to keep it in top shape.
Paintbrush Guard - How long will painted brick last? Durability, factors, tips
Exterior brick painting: This article explores what is the downside of painting brick, shedding light on the challenges of brick painting to help you make an informed choice.
Paintbrush Guard - What is the downside of painting brick and what to consider.
Learn more about exterior brick paint types: The wrong paint can trap moisture, damage brick, or peel quickly, leading to costly repairs. Here are key reasons to focus on paint type when painting brick exteriors.
Paintbursh Guard - What Kind of Paint Do You Use on Exterior Brick?
Less Waste, More Efficiency
Find tutorials on how to paint your house interior and exterior surfaces
Learn about eco-friendly painting, tips and tutorials on house interior and exterior surfaces, so you can get started with your project without any surprices during or after your painting.
Learn about mood impact & room preference for interior paint colors
Learn how interior house paint colors influence mood with expert tips on room preference so you can pick the best colors for a harmonious home environment.
We focus on the most popular shades for each interior colors, so you don't miss no matter what color you pick.
Learn about the benefits of Paintbrush Guard vacuum storage
Learn how this innovative tool allows you to store paintbrushes without the need for immediate cleaning, offering significant advantages in time savings, water conservation, reduced chemical pollution, and lower costs for supplies.